Hernandez reasoned one simple court sanction of a sexual relationship you will never be the only real evidence that any particular one try an actual and you can moral resident

Somehow my suggestion happens from the earliest and you will important institution out-of relationships, however, regardless of if we’re in support of marriage, as is fitting of males whom create laws and regulations for all those, we wish to calmly believe people’s genuine disease. Taking into consideration one legislation derives out-of facts, such boys features united here to write a composition which wipes brush the fresh problems of history and you can tries a separate road for future years, [thus] it is necessary which they judiciously analysis brand new requirements your land and you can visited the finish that there exists some thing inside our everyday life plus in our world to which we can’t within the any way romantic the attention, we need certainly to deal with valiantly. 51

By saying you to definitely an effective disjuncture stayed anywhere between legislators’ beliefs and you can “social fact,” Hernandez contended you to she are attacking to possess Cubans who were maybe not are not considered models of sexual propriety and, ergo, had been unjustly disenfranchised

You will find arrived at this new Assembly in order to sparingly protect, into best of my personal ability, the Cuban girl, brand new partnered girl, the latest single lady, the latest light woman, this new black colored lady, lady of all categories. I must claim that there are a great number of Cuban feamales in hard and you can humiliating products, who’re as honorable and also as worth quality once the are most other lady, that just given that she actually is for the a totally free union, doesn’t mean that people should think about this lady along with her household members depraved. 52

Twenty-a couple from the 60-half a dozen Set up people gonna this new session voted so you can approve Hernandez’s offer. The majority of those who chosen from inside the prefer reasoned this manage assist males into the consensual unions to get to know a similar commitments and you may commitments that partnered males was in fact bound to meet and you can, thus, perform include all women and children. Such, progressive Installation affiliate Capablanca contended Las Vegas singles you to definitely “although it [Hernandez’s modification] looks paradoxical, far from getting…an attack on matrimony, it’s a coverage from it.” 53 The guy told me, “Whenever people know that he or she is accountable for female which have which he’s got an effective consensual commitment and for the college students one to influence from all of these 100 % free unions, they cannot participate in consensual unions however in relationship.” 54 Capablanca illustrated men since the nearly naturally irresponsible, and you will created that women called for Condition protection from them. Anybody else echoed his rationale.

Although not, the majority of Assembly players, progressives and you may traditionals, balked at the Hernandez’s idea, arguing that it was not that lead so you’re able to democratic progress and you may perform offer legal rights and you will privileges in order to undeserving, immoral people. Traditional Assembly associate Cortina contributed an effective demanding struggle up against Hernandez’s offer, creating their dissent because the a combat having modernity, progress, and you can civilization. The guy mentioned that a beneficial constitutional ensure to take on consensual unions equivalent in order to judge marriage ceremonies do basically posting Cuba out of with the an appropriate street divergent regarding that of “all the gentle countries on earth” and you will “destroy…the new matrimonial system, making [it] totally inadequate.” 55 Cortina prophesied, “Whether or not it modification was in fact approved, we might develop a massive frustration within the legal married life, therefore we manage make the effects of political trend and that you will find simply stayed using, so you’re able to circles your psychological and you will family unit members lifetime, [sectors] and this won’t need to be transformed regarding the revolutionary and you will perturbing way that was proposed.” 56 For Cortina, this new 1933 trend is actually a governmental wave, and after that reform would be to simply connect with government: Personal activities should be kept by yourself.