Will when schedules are supplied, they are considering having 24 hours of month one do maybe not fits thereupon day because when you look at the genuine records. One such analogy takes place in Harry Potter in addition to Prisoner regarding Azkaban when Sybill Trelawney means sixteen Oct just like the Saturday, even if 16 Oct 1993 are a monday.

There are also contradictions for the courses in this area. Particularly, in Harry Potter together with Cup regarding Fire, one another 1 September and 2 September are given just like the Mondays and, during the Harry Potter and also the Prisoner out-of Azkaban, Buckbeak’s trial is decided to your 20 April, however, careful parsing of your text message reveals that it could possess occurred zero later on than just February.

And additionally, inside the Harry Potter therefore the Cup away from Fire they state your Champions was picked towards the Saturday 29 October, however, 30 Oct was a monday inside the 1994.

From inside the a bankruptcy proceeding of Quidditch From Many years, they say that earliest Quidditch Globe Mug occured into the 1473. If for example the tournament are kept every four years, this problems towards declaration in the Goblet out of Flames that the 1994 Globe Mug is actually the brand new 422nd. In the event the Quidditch From the Age is good, the brand new 422nd Quidditch World Mug would in fact fall in the year 3161, in case Cup off Fire is useful, the initial Industry Glass ended up being held in the 306.

Historic trouble [ ]

As the series, with regards to the schedule based on the Chamber from Treasures resource, is determined in the 1990s, brand new show usually looks as though it is set in new late nineties so you can mid-2000s, more or less concurrent towards publication of your own courses. Within the Harry Potter plus the Half-Blood Prince, Cornelius Fudge spends a male pronoun to refer into “predecessor” of Best Minister of your Uk. Depending on the over schedule, this will take place in the summertime regarding 1996, in the event the Best Minister was John Biggest, whose instant ancestor was a woman (is why basic interviewing Fudge, the book says the newest election, but Biggest was not 1st opted for and only got more than just after Thatcher retired.

You are able, however unrealistic, you to Fudge might possibly be speaing frankly about a far more faraway predecessor, because Thatcher took workplace before Fudge supposedly became Minister having Wonders. (Even if one can possibly think a situation in which Fudge try delegated of the Minister for Wonders to get to know to your Finest Minister while he, Fudge, was at a smaller office.) On top of that, the fresh new identification and you will reputation of the top Minister depicted appears to so much more closely fits that of Tony Blair than of John Biggest. A post throughout the Every day Mail notes you to definitely Rowling try romantic on the next-Chancellor of your own Exchequer Gordon Brown (usually seen as a competitor to Blair’s leadership of Work Class, which been successful him and you can became Best Minister) kaunis Intialainen lady, and therefore she has been attempting to let you know Blair’s terrible top. In case your courses had been place in connect with publication date from Philosopher’s Stone, following it experience perform take place in 2002 (just after Blair turned into Prime Minister).

However, it was later stated that twenty two November try a saturday, which it was at 1994

A similar problem relates to Nicolas Flamel, who was mentioned as being 665 at the time of the newest earliest guide, however, Nicolas Flamel are a bona-fide historical figure and you will wouldn’t have reached you to definitely years up until 1996, within day the first publication are penned. The latest rebuttal for this is the fact that go out this new “real” Nicolas Flamel came to be will not talk to the latest Nicolas Flamel of Harry Potter.

An alternative state is present out-of Rubeus Hagrid’s period because the Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It’s created regarding the show one Hagrid got you to definitely status in this a few years out of their expulsion out of college or university from inside the 1942. However in you to definitely world off Harry Potter together with Cup of Flame, Molly Weasley reminisces on the Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper appear to overlap that have Molly’s years in school, it looks unrealistic you to she remembers an earlier gamekeeper. not, you will be able you to Hagrid don’t be a good gamekeeper quickly once becoming expelled, but rather become as Ogg’s secretary. This really is probable since whenever Harry thinks that he tend to end up being expelled getting flying to your broomstick in place of permission in the first year, he magic in the event that however be permitted to remain on since the Hagrid’s assistant.